The Chosen (2026) s6e02
Is it bad that I'm hoping we get some daylight at some point, so I can snap a decent screen-grab?
Not uncommonly in a season of The Chosen, there are a couple of episodes where not much really happens as the writers start building the foundations for the rest of the season. And this episode is classic in that respect. The plot here barely moves on here at all. The main body of Jesus' followers talk and eventually leave Mary, Martha and Lazarus' house; Peter and John edge closer towards Peter's fateful date with a campfire; and even Jesus only faces a questioning at the hands of Annas, Caiaphas' father-in-law and predecessor as high priest.
This isn't a criticism, but it does mean the points of interest in this episode are subtler.
Take for example, the opening scene, where Caiaphas' granddaughter, (Shoshanna?), wakes him. It's a simple scene, but it's the first time we've seen a sympathetic, human side to the High Priest, who has, so far, been the driving factor behind Jesus' death. He still seems pretty set on "the prophecy" though. I might have to go back a revisit that scene at some point. In John's Gospel it seems that Caiaphas says it in a general way, as a pragmatic half-suggestion, but John explains that Caiaphas was unknowingly giving a specific prophecy. Anyway, however he said it originally, here it seems to be very much a driving force behind his determination to kill Jesus. He wholeheartedly believes God has told him to kill Jesus. Or does he? There's just a flicker as he says "and political expediency just happens to align with what I've been shown" that might suggest, that the prophecy is fake and is all about political expediency. Like I say, subtle.
Or look at the scene where Caiaphas sits down with Annas and Ananus, whose confusingly similar names and close family ties (Ananus is married to Caiaphas's sister and is Annas's son) are a nod to Josephus more than the Gospels which only name Annas. Indeed only John mentions him in relation to this trial. There's no historical reason to imagine this scene happened. It seems more of an attempt to tidy up the slightly differing accounts of who Jesus saw when in the four Gospels. Mark says Jesus saw the unnamed high priest, plus "the chief priests and the whole council" (14:55). Matthew calls the high priest Caiaphas (26:57) and retains the mention of the chief priests and the whole council. Both agree this happened before the cock crowed. Luke locates these events later ("when day came", 22:66) and after a beating by the crowd who seized him in Gethsemane (no mention of soldiers in Matthew, Mark and Luke) and he also doesn't name Caiaphas. But John has them lead Jesus to Annas first (whom he seems to call "high priest" as well) for an interrogation and only later to Caiaphas.
So quite what Ananus is doing there is anyone's guess. Perhaps it will become clear later, maybe as a way to harmonise the above. Anyway, Caiaphas mentions his prophecy again.
Another minor, but important little exchange occurs between Judas and John. Judas still believes he's made the right decision at this point, even if he sees how it must look to the others. He talks about loving God with your mind. Again this is fairly new ground for gospel adaptations. A handful of them have Judas speak to one of the others after the arrest. Jesus (Roger Young, 1999) has Judas and Peter argue and scuffle and Mary Magdalene (Garth Davis, 2018) is interesting in this respect too, though I don't have time to remind myself what happens there right now. But this is longer, and while Judas still believes whatever he believed that motivated him to "betray" Jesus. It's before he repents and returns the 30 pieces of silver. I guess he gets a whole song in Jesus Christ Superstar (Norman Jewison, 1973), but hopefully you see my point.
We also get to find out a bit more about Matthias (a.k.a. "The Watcher") who encounters the women followers on the road back to Jerusalem and later turns up to see the men and encourage them to leave the house at Bethany.
Jesus is then questioned by Annas and Ananus, and the latter does strike Jesus during proceedings. Jesus is not silent, but certainly concise and evasive. One interesting thing he does say is "there's no shortage of record keeping as to my words and teachings". This again feels like The Chosen as an apologetic. Even within the show we've only really seen Matthew and John taking records, Annas has no access to their records, so what other records is he talking about? Again it gives the impression that the words in the Gospels are better attested than is supported by the evidence.
Annas ultimately is not-persuaded that Jesus needs to die, so Caiaphas refers to the prophecy again. And then he says this: "The prophecy says one man will die for the people, but it doesn't say who will perpetrate that death". Both seem to agree he needs to die, but that they should hand him over.
So at the end we're not much further on and we've only covered a tiny portion of the verses left in the Gospels, but hopefully you agree that the territory that's been covered, and how it's been covered, is very interesting.
Read my thoughts on season 6 episode 1>>
Labels: The Chosen: Season 6
















0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home